ĐẠI HỌC QUỐC GIA HÀ NỘI
TRƯỜNG ĐẠI HỌC KHOA HỌC XÃ HỘI VÀ NHÂN VĂN
NGUYỄN THỊ BÌNH
SỰ NGHIỆP NGHIÊN CỨU PHÊ BÌNH VĂN HỌC
CỦA NHÀ VĂN TRƯƠNG TỬU
Luận văn Thạc sĩ chuyên ngành: Văn học Việt Nam
Mã số: 60 22 34
Hà Nội - 2013

ĐẠI HỌC QUỐC GIA HÀ NỘI
TRƯỜNG ĐẠI HỌC KHOA HỌC XÃ HỘI VÀ NHÂN VĂN
NGUYỄN THỊ BÌNH
SỰ NGHIỆP NGHIÊN CỨU PHÊ BÌNH VĂN HỌC
CỦA NHÀ VĂN TRƯƠNG TỬU
Luận văn Thạc sĩ chuyên ngành: Văn học Việt Nam
Mã số: 60 22 34
Người hướng dẫn khoa học: PGS.TS. NGUYỄN BÁ THÀNH
Hà Nội - 2013

LỜI CAM ĐOAN

 !"#$%&'&'()*#+%,-./01+
2341.1567-(/0+34189%:(7'
;#-<=>1?-<7=
 -#!@-0'
Hà Nội, Ngày tháng năm 2013
#,
Nguyễn Thị Bình
A
B
THÔNG TIN VỀ LUẬN VĂN THẠC SĨ

DW1WS=iD#lM[!JX'
'B'*4D4M2>[#>m
W^>no->VW-01'Rl
c-@QM,;Xk24M!=
W,'/JX#V`D>17#
#[Q M>M@-7-6Q'3<[Q>#>m>"
"#V`Dk^'&7<e
?V,@QD!6#^WV#
f!<VW4/(Qk2[?>p;c-
l--;=MT1!#,XV#f!<-01
/(4'
'.,0``)Cb@-0[f
>,WS=--01'
Rq(*r:st(%uv( (%swx:yR:xz(
PGS.TS. Nguyn B Thnh Nguyn Thị Bình
E
INFORMATION ON MASTER’S THESIS
'{|C(|*'&|C{||
A'u|}WCu||W|E

GHI
B'$|}WC:(
L'K  |  W|C IIA  |  ~|  

 NN  W  •|  }
€-|}&||:|Q/|((€-|Q:
('
E'R||V|C(
H'~}}||CUR|||}•|
Y

'KVVWV|C|W||}|}|||}
|}||'
&€$…•/x&~•ad u|CLFNA
&|C
‡‡‡‡‡‡‡
K'$}'Q$u'{|C Nguyen Thi
Binh
Nguyen Ba Thanh
I
LỜI CẢM ƠN
cX2-lWMJ\M"#$%&'&'
()*#+26Ml7-Q@ eVˆ
@-0'
5cX2,J^MTg"#
>/01‰##W7-2341.1567-
(/06T-eVˆT#@-0'
Hà Nội, Ngày tháng năm 2013
#,
Nguyễn Thị Bình
G
MỤC LỤC
ZŠRbŠR N
Z‹3Œ€ L
'bg1<''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''L
'b;X-^<'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''E
A'39c-V4->,#'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''H
B'(-`''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''H
L'$JV#V''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''H
E'R^e@-0''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''I
RJ G

>•„žNQ'NBŸ'3<[WM›Q"
4-1W›@,'/M342#
„>l91-7,a9d7M7
"ea(Xid#34V,M
^TM-742=-`4„'ulWe!
QJX6#(^b-S!67'
>l^2;^V@Q;>^V` 
”Q\Vh!W^>n)#'*P17„V#
D[1„1fT<c!-V,>#4¡
k#':JW^#16gcT<2!
'JX›b„4Wf#9!6
4„'&Po[-@WP„64>TMo-`
g-67Q64>V,kV[Q0Q4
c„žNQ'NLŸ'3i72-@QVWœ

2W\b\<-2Cu?-'
HH
'''JX-##!MbDQb.Qb1bQ
b' HG
MbD„Z7oP"9,,>ne„'.MVe-DWV
W!JXQ7,)@^79VW^
T|7i,Q<>9!-0f#m
7#Vj?2#,'3[[f|7
=W\"7W!' IN
(MMbDoP"9,,>neb.c
o!ie-fM;X'3-W-MQJX
W\"W›#-^<=^lWjQ›4
>MDV"-k221^cQ‰
?7fM-M-<ieb.[>#
-MbD'MbD„c,if,TM79;Q

,-`e-;fe7,'š,^WoQo
\‰Q1-@Q,W6"7W„žEŸ
4,2MV`W;l''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''GN
'A'JX-79-^<g@-01'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''G
'A''*-<J-0/( G
'A''8-<## GE
R:s•(%A NN
Zr&•(¥x¦€*x§€•~(%$:~(%RqR: NN
(%:x¦(R¨€O$:¦*©(:/•(:•RRªK•s•(%Ž€ NN
A''$JV#V>#TQ>1''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''N
A''b9-09Q\,Q=@'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''
A'A'„R#=7#-W,om‡„'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''L
.«b€™( 
A
’xbxz€:KZ.:¬~ A
B
MỞ ĐẦU
1. Lý do chọn đề tài
JX7Dg@VW7M<
M'š7DVWV6VW/
(-24'JX-M:-/?(1$'
JX?We-@`VJV#VVW!M>]
55'*-M"!WTriết lí truyện KiềuĐông Tây tuần
báo0GAQ0^GS-1fe'i[
2#4V=-014:(7'JX
SMi0GAL-4WVW-MW#Loa<
Văn học Việt Nam hiện đại.
iT-<-0JQVW-01MVJV#VV
WQ‡JX<[D[[V7#'/-@-f
V-VW-01!JXQ##-;=!

T!<-VW-01,<(-
<*\'
‹<*\Q4V=Tiên Phong#9QAaGBLd-9EaGBEdQ
3hZWe*[WPhê bình tập sách Tương lai
văn nghệ Việt Nam của Trương Tửu'W-MQ#,67
@”=>#T#CU3#MJX<o7
-^<-07#"!-MJM9f|4e
E
7JM'@V@#!JXT#
-<V"g@Q->WMJ74[g
>MT#œœQT#U#[Y-6pDf^"M
7<-0YžBQHŸ'
i0GLIMGIE!MDWU#Y-VV#TM
T-0J-VJV#VVW!JX'
(0GLI>>=[Wm!7^9Nhân
văn giai phẩm, $R3[W-MCThái độ và phương pháp giảng dạy
của Trương TửuW#Độc lập'W-MQ$3R›C
UJX#,>=-64QW V#f¢
?#Q-Y'#,l-MCUJX4-0
[X`|VJV#V@!TfW-
@V2-0V,7!YžBŸ'.œ-@Ql
›CUJX2[WiW6Q4\cQcV,
;#U^\|Y>#-M#
-'Uu`g!JXe,4^7'
R[f[JX6<"4#f"7P
!-'''$JV#V-01!JXVJ
V#V!TQ=>|Q”Q|g
9#!'/<#7=;[!oJ7QV,
7Qc`2JfV^2Q[MQ[M>#7
##PYžBŸ'R9‰M7>M@>#\CU/7

W^V`‰-V,>#a'''dJX!J@V7
-0Q>;64!7,MQœ[f
I
cV#-,=;7#6D„'/ 2!:
W“ Thực chất của Trương Tửu”-MC„W@VGiai PhẩmMVQ
[,>=@-W7#W73,V`##-0QV!
@=^#=Q=^-,!,'/ 79-
W;VWc?Q[œ[[f#4'Z7h[W[V
”QW;h-f->9'''7h>#[42[!#
6`„'
b4W$V#UMấy vấn đề văn học sử Việt NamY!JXQ
2cVc<@V"7^Q>!c^
6"^'(DTM;h>ih|We9-
D#`f6cW9':JA#^4W
VV#9-01X^7c>=Q0,
<>nW#Văn họciLFGFGLIM90GLI'
JX6W;DWe[M‰2:Q
(^9Q3%Qb:/-'-'''V,9D7'#
EFGLGQ9:D-MC„ReOJX-"3,O9
WM417V#V,#4W1ee@Q-
@i-;=^Qe6-0o=D#
W#V,7^QD#Vj!9O.VJQ‰D
!W1V,#4QW1”4T9M„(trích Bọn Nhân Văn
Giai Phẩm Trước Tòa Án Dư Luận, tr. 161)'
(MP<*\>(/0%$jQS-#
Vj!JXW;4iQP<(Q,PJXO
()*#.41^'()/0W7Lược
Khảo Văn HọcQ@VW-MC„()*#.2"-7
^67TVW_-#V`[7#[
G

>=Mh‰!@i'
%4@;-<JX[¢^2
W4‰2!JXOJ()/-' ()/-6
V#17-01>#7#-<JXCUJX
[>MD-g@'b2[!7,Vj!#[Q
g@!7<DV9=h¢Q>M4
4Q- ?-7@-M;'K7‰W
Wj‡YžEQ'OAŸ'
3M-0 ()3Re14) JX4:
(7 GOOGGG @,7Q[f[ [7œ
J, [[4:U"J®R#-T!"lP
,7-^-,Q1›'*P‰,7[1›Q"
W›W,o-0-9[!Q6D^,QW
kQfi[Q- MV`9[=QT"Q
72Y'
|3hbQ71l!JXQ‰
>1QJX£[D>M@Q
£#[W,=oV9Q- 2[
œ#-^;>V,2V,W77##W;
;XT>M'$%&O&():D&J?>p;72J
X7£D0"QD7^"
Q^-1@-¢V,'

(0NNBQ;*#3o-Mcác hình thái tư duy phê bình đầu thế kỷ
XX04V=Hồn ViệtQ9'W-MQ;*#3o[-<
VW>1!"Z4QbQ3uKQ
|QUVW>14Mf^V,P
()*#.'R[f1VW!()*#.VW
>1YžEQGŸ'i2@”=>p;^Q;*#
3o6#m-^<74#VjCNguyễn Du và Truyện

V##7#>1Q>#TDh\@P
.<YžLGŸ'
(0NNHQ29# Trương Tửu – tuyển tập
nghiên cứu phê bìnhQ():D&J-;*#3o6W77M9
-<7We"0O6-7UWWe-`#-0Y^'
‹W-MQ():D&J-;*#3o@V[-<VW
>1!JX'URD>1cJX‰-
oQ^QU>#TYV=##>Qc¯
Q>,0-@`#gM!DW7>1
g1Q<1Q671'''-VW-0JYžHŸ'
3#eg^Q0NNIQ>œGL0!
JX777,-<cS4341&V4:
(7';V[6[74W-M-<2QV-
2P!c0#W#4C
*-M ! ();*6fW0>0!
?!,M-<JXQWP1U>fD
D2>M#h;^\|--9kS-i"
A
<#V`-i>M@‰\YžHŸ'i724
7!JXQ();*6^
a''d'#[QW>p;VW
U,=#U1,JXY'''b2U2
>1YQ1VJV#VVW-01Q44
`79MM¤MV@iVJ'š!
7Q<^DT[=V-01
XYžHŸ'3k2QW?W77#V`-<D#;J
Xf4##Vj!'U31<W-M
#JXM>œQe#V`7=W#Q!
MW›21[fMV@cDgM4
-?^V4V-<-0[Q-01ki[<^c>=g

D@”-MV`-=e\!@
”Y'RlJXU>474<Qk[#V
`i#,YžBŸQi[V”V1eD>M@
‰|U4,Y!i2'R=-MQc-^
=24!'(-@Qi21M9V
W-#,4!JXQ^,<^Q^JXQ
P?fc#=!'R[¢[?7
Dg.<Z&J›U%# JXO(24
9!=”'|.<Z&JQUJX-0
@VM-^-,-P!!':J00Q- V
#JQ#^¢V,Q#!=Q>
-M79W#@VGiai PhẩmV#WfTf-<-0
L